EPIDEMIOLOGY AND CLINICAL COURSE
In the United States, the lifetime and past-year prevalence of social anxiety disorder
is approximately 13% and 7%, respectively.
14,124 The male-to-female prevalence
9 Social anxiety disorder usually begins early in life, with
a mean onset between ages 14 and 16 years.
125 More than 50% of patients are
affected before adolescence, and a history of shyness and behavioral inhibition
throughout childhood is common.
125 Unless effectively treated, the clinical course is
often chronic, unremitting, and lifelong, and only 20% to 40% of patients are
reported to recover after 20 years of living with this condition.
COMORBIDITY AND CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE
Comorbidity in social anxiety disorder is high, with an estimated 70% to 90% of
individuals having at least one other psychiatric disorder in their lifetime.
Common comorbid conditions include simple phobia, major depression, GAD, panic
disorder, body dysmorphic disorder, and alcohol abuse. Because of its early onset,
social anxiety disorder usually precedes the development of comorbid disorders.
Alcohol is commonly used to decrease anxiety in social situations. The risk of
suicide attempts is high, especially in those with both social anxiety disorder and
another psychiatric illness, like depression.
Because social anxiety disorder usually begins during the teenage years, it can
seriously interfere with development of normal social skills, achievement of full
academic and career potentials, and abilities to form interpersonal relationships.
This leads to functional disabilities that may persist for a lifetime. Social anxiety
disorder is associated with unemployment, lower levels of education, and
dependence on public financial support systems.
disorder are less likely to marry, and more than half report moderate-to-severe
impairments in their abilities to carry out ordinary daily activities.
Social anxiety disorder is a familial disease, but the relative contributions of genetic
versus environmental influences have not been differentiated.
predisposing to its development include anxious behavior modeling in parents and
1 Shyness in children, which is associated with later
development of social anxiety disorder, has been linked to a specific genetic
polymorphism of the serotonin transporter promoter region.
Biologic studies suggest performance-only social anxiety disorder has a different
underlying pathophysiology involving noradrenergic system dysfunction. Conversely,
in nonperformance-only social anxiety disorder, there is substantial evidence for
dopaminergic (decreased dopamine neurotransmission) and serotonergic dysfunction
(5-HT type-2 receptor hypersensitivity).
TREATMENT OF SOCIAL ANXIETY DISORDER
Early detection and treatment of social anxiety disorder are vital in reducing lifelong
functional consequences and may prevent development of comorbid disorders.
Because of the nature of the disorder, some sufferers are reluctant to seek treatment
resulting in an average treatment delay of 16 years.
131 Those who seek help, even in
psychiatric settings, are rarely diagnosed and treated appropriately.
Pharmacotherapy has become first line, but nonpharmacotherapy, particularly CBT,
20 Data do not support the routine use of combined modalities in the
management of social anxiety disorder; clinicians should determine whether
combined therapy would be useful on a case-by-case basis.
Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors and Serotonin and Norepinephrine
As with other anxiety disorders, SSRIs, in addition to the SNRI venlafaxine, are
considered the primary treatment option for most patients with social anxiety
for which paroxetine, sertraline, fluvoxamine CR, and venlafaxine XR are
132 Nonetheless, fluoxetine, citalopram, and escitalopram have also
demonstrated efficacy in controlled clinical trials although fluoxetine has negative
20,132 Preliminary evidence with duloxetine suggests this agent may
Unlike patients with GAD and panic disorder, those with social anxiety disorder
often tolerate standard antidepressant starting doses. Target doses for social anxiety
disorder are typically within the normal antidepressant dosage ranges. It is thought
SSRIs exhibit a flat dose–response curve.
134 Fixed-dose studies of paroxetine (20,
40, and 60 mg/day) and duloxetine (≥60 mg/day) in social anxiety disorder found no
overall difference in efficacy between doses.
133,135 Although some individuals may
require higher dosages, adequate time (2–4 weeks) should be allowed before the
dosage is increased. Response to SSRIs occurs gradually, and an adequate
medication trial to assess response should last at least 8 to 10 weeks. Many who
experience minimal response at week 8 may show a good response at week 12, and
improvements have been found to continue throughout 16 weeks of treatment.
The MAOIs phenelzine (60–90 mg/day), tranylcypromine (30–60 mg/day), and
selegiline (5 mg twice daily) have also demonstrated marked efficacy for social
anxiety disorder but are reserved for SSRI nonresponders.
Case reports and open studies suggest bupropion may be useful in treating social
anxiety disorder, but controlled trials are needed to define its role.
conflicting evidence from small RCTs but may be considered in SSRI
Imipramine is ineffective for social anxiety disorder, and TCAs
(except clomipramine) are not among the recommended treatment options.
Likewise, nefazodone is not recommended given the risk of hepatotoxicity and
conflicting evidence, including one negative RCT.
Benzodiazepines are generally considered second-line therapy for social anxiety
disorder, as they have limited efficacy in treating psychiatric comorbidities and
abuse/dependence potential. In clinical practice, they are commonly used in
combination with SSRI therapy on an as-needed basis before participation in
132 However, the efficacy of adjunctive benzodiazepines to
decrease time to response or increase response rate is unclear.
benzodiazepines may be useful as monotherapy in select patients. Clonazepam (1–3
mg/day) was markedly efficacious in one controlled study, whereas alprazolam (1–6
mg/day) showed only modest efficacy compared with placebo.
β-Blockers and Other Miscellaneous Agents
β-Adrenergic receptor blockers reduce peripheral autonomic symptoms of anxiety
and, thus, are useful for performance-related social anxiety disorder.
(10–80 mg) and atenolol (25–50 mg) are the two recommended agents and can be
used on an as-needed basis (1–2 hours before the performance) to reduce
anxiety symptoms such as tremors, palpitations, and blushing. A test dose should be
tried before the actual occasion to assess tolerability.
Pregabalin is also considered to be an acceptable first-line agent, in the absence of
comorbidities which would benefit from an SSRI, based on placebo-controlled trials
for acute management and relapse prevention.
It appears a higher pregabalin dose
(450–600 mg/day) may be necessary for effective treatment. Other anticonvulsants,
antipsychotics, and miscellaneous agents have also been reported to be effective in
the treatment of social anxiety disorder, but they are considered second- or third-line
20,43,132 These include gabapentin, tiagabine, topiramate, valproate
derivatives, olanzapine monotherapy, adjunctive aripiprazole, adjunctive
Several studies have demonstrated CBT to be comparable to medications in the
treatment of social anxiety disorder.
139 Although medications may work faster, CBT
is believed to result in longer-lasting treatment gains with effects persisting for 1 to 5
years. The cognitive therapy component changes maladaptive thought patterns, such
as expectations of performing poorly and over concern about negative evaluation by
139 The behavioral therapy component, as in other anxiety disorders, involves
repeated exposure and practice performing in those feared situations. Social skills
training can also be beneficial in improving interpersonal communication skills.
CLINICAL PRESENTATION OF SOCIAL ANXIETY DISORDER
something stupid” when he is around people and becomes extremely embarrassed when he has to talk to
social anxiety disorder are present in S.H.?
S.H. exhibits many characteristic features of the generalized type of social anxiety
disorder. S.H. admits he does not like being around people for fear of
embarrassment, and he generally avoids social situations, which are classic traits of
social anxiety disorder. Symptoms of blushing and shaking voice are also common in
social anxiety disorder, as well as other typical anxiety symptoms such as
palpitations, trembling, sweating, tense muscles, dry throat, hot/cold sensations, and
a sinking feeling in the stomach. S.H. also displays hypersensitivity to rejection and
low self-esteem, and he realizes his behavior and fears are unreasonable. These
symptoms and S.H.’s young age are consistent with a diagnosis of social anxiety
S.H.’s case illustrates the substantial disability that can result from this illness.
S.H.’s anxiety disorder has deprived him of normal social development, making
friends, dating, participating in social functions regularly, and pursuit of higher
education. Future impairments throughout S.H.’s life are likely to be significant
unless his anxiety is treated successfully.
TREATMENT SELECTION FOR SOCIAL ANXIETY DISORDER
prescribed pharmacotherapy appropriate in this case?
Because S.H.’s generalized social anxiety disorder is severely affecting his life,
medication treatment is indicated. SSRIs are first-line therapy for treating social
anxiety disorder, and sertraline is a good choice because it is FDA-approved for this
indication and available as a generic. Although not applicable in this case, sertraline
is also effective for many other psychiatric disorders commonly seen in patients with
social anxiety disorder. The sertraline starting dose of 50 mg/day is appropriate for
S.H., and 50-mg increment dosage increases can be made every 4 weeks according to
response, up to a maximum of 200 mg/day. Signs of response may be seen within 2 to
4 weeks, but 8 to 12 weeks is usually required for optimal results. If available, CBT
may also be combined with pharmacotherapy for S.H.
GOALS AND DURATION OF TREATMENT
CASE 83-8, QUESTION 3: What are the goals of treatment in this case, and how can S.H.’s response to
treatment be objectively assessed? How long should effective therapy be continued?
Three principle domains of treatment outcomes have been defined for social
anxiety disorder: symptoms, functionality, and overall well-being.
recommended that all three of these areas are assessed because even if all anxiety
symptoms disappear, treatment is not clinically significant unless functioning also
improves. The clinician-rated Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale and the patient-rated
Sheehan Disability Scale can be used for measuring improvements in symptom and
functional ability domains, respectively.
In S.H.’s case, the desired outcomes of
treatment include reducing fear and avoidance of social situations, enabling him to
comfortably interact socially and attend college, and improving his quality of life.
Several studies have examined relapse rates after double-blind discontinuation of
effective treatment in social anxiety disorder.
132,136,139 Long-term studies have shown
sertraline, paroxetine, escitalopram, fluvoxamine CR, venlafaxine XR, pregabalin,
and clonazepam prevent relapse of social anxiety disorder during continuation
20 Therefore, pharmacotherapy should be continued for at least 1 year after
125,132 After that time, a gradual medication discontinuation trial may be
attempted with vigilant monitoring for signs of relapse.
POST-TRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER AND
PTSD and acute stress disorder occur in people who have experienced a severely
distressing traumatic event. These disorders are
characterized by symptoms of intrusive re-experiencing, avoidance features,
autonomic hyperarousal, and negative cognitions and mood symptoms.
war veterans, PTSD also occurs in persons exposed to events such as natural
disasters, serious accidents, criminal assault, rape, physical or sexual abuse, and
political victimization (refugees, concentration camp survivors, hostages). The
trauma does not have to involve physical injury to the PTSD victim. Witnessing
someone else being injured or killed, being diagnosed with a life-threatening illness,
and experiencing the unexpected death of a loved one are common types of trauma
Symptoms of PTSD are presented in Table 83-11.
criteria, the person must have exposure to actual or threatened death, serious injury,
or sexual violence via directly experiencing the event, witnessing the event in person,
learning the event occurred to a close family member or friend, or experiencing
extreme exposure to aversive details of an event.
1 Specifiers indicate whether PTSD
is delayed (after 6 months) onset in relation to the trauma and/or whether it is
associated with dissociative symptoms.
1 Symptoms must persist for at least 1 month
to meet the criteria for PTSD. Acute stress disorder is a separate diagnostic category
in the DSM-5 and refers to cases in which symptoms last less than 1 month (but at
It involves many of the same clinical features as PTSD, and like with
PTSD, symptoms must be severe enough to interfere with functioning.
Epidemiology and Clinical Course
PTSD is associated with a lifetime prevalence in the general population of
approximately 10% and up to 24% among deployed serviceman from Iraq and
140 PTSD is twice as common in women, although overall, men are
141 Rates of PTSD are expected to rise as the frequency
of traumatic events throughout the world continues to increase. An estimated 80% to
90% of individuals in the United States today will experience at least one event
during their lifetime traumatic enough to lead to PTSD.
Most people who are exposed to a traumatic event do not develop PTSD;
approximately 90% of individuals experience a normal acute stress response to
141 Risk factors for the development of PTSD include
experiencing assaultive violence, more severe and chronic traumas, a history of
depressive or anxiety disorders, lack of social support after the trauma, and
experiencing dissociative or other intense symptoms during or soon after the
140–142 Previous exposure to trauma also increases the risk of developing
PTSD after later traumas, and survivors of childhood sexual or physical abuse have
been found to be especially vulnerable.
Overall, 79% to 88% of PTSD patients also suffer from other disorders in their
lifetime, including major depression, alcohol or other substance abuse, GAD, panic
disorder, and phobic disorders.
140,141,143–145 The risk of suicidality in PTSD is high
and likely influenced by comorbid major depression.
found associations with PTSD and coronary heart disease, traumatic brain injury, and
147–149 PTSD causes significant functional disability and has been
associated with school failure, teenage pregnancy, unemployment, marital instability,
legal problems, and impaired performance in the workplace.
The course of PTSD is highly variable. Most patients who meet criteria for PTSD
1 month after trauma show spontaneous recovery within 6 to 9 months.
continues for years in a significant minority, estimated at 10% to 25%, and some
sufferers experience a lifelong course of illness.
Psychological trauma, especially that which occurs early in life or is chronic in
duration, can cause persistent changes in various aspects of brain functioning and in
neurobiologic responses to stress.
151 Evidence of altered NE, 5-HT, glutamatergic,
GABA system, HPA axis, neuroendocrine, substance P, and opioid system
functioning has been found in PTSD.
152–155 Stress-induced hyperactivity of central
noradrenergic systems is believed to lead to the generalized anxiety and autonomic
hyperarousal associated with PTSD.
Neurobiologic consequences of stress and trauma result in both structural and
functional changes in the brain, including reduced hippocampal volume and
excessive activation of the amygdala.
156 Genetic factors may also play a role in
influencing vulnerability to the damaging effects of stress.
Symptoms of Post-traumatic Stress Disorder for Individuals ê6 Years of Age
reminders such as places, people, conversations about or related to the event)
Increased arousal including at least two of the following:
Irritability or anger outbursts
Reckless of self-destructive behavior
Negative beliefs or expectations about oneself, others, or the world
Diminished interest or participation in activities
Lack of ability to experience positive emotions
Treatment of Post-traumatic Stress Disorder
Both medications and CBT are useful in treating PTSD. Nonpharmacologic therapies
alone may be appropriate for initial treatment of mild PTSD, but pharmacotherapy,
either alone or in some instances in combination with psychological therapies, may
be recommended for patients with moderate or severe illness.
assessing various treatment options for PTSD, it is important to consider effects on
all four core symptom clusters (re-experiencing or intrusive symptoms, avoidance,
hyperarousal, or negative cognitions and mood symptoms). Not all PTSD treatments
are effective for each domain.
The preferred first-line medications in PTSD are SSRIs or the SNRI, venlafaxine
XR, but various other antidepressants may also be useful. Response to
pharmacotherapy occurs very gradually, taking 8 to 12 weeks or longer. Partial
response at 12 weeks of treatment may be followed by full remission after several
more months of therapy; therefore, an adequate period should be allowed to fully
determine response to a particular medication. Lack of improvement after 4 weeks of
therapy indicates nonresponse, so alternative treatment strategies should be tried in
159 Although further research is needed, prevention of PTSD using various
pharmacologic strategies has been evaluated in adults. A recent review highlights
potential utility of hydrocortisone, but additional studies are needed.
SELECTIVE SEROTONIN REUPTAKE INHIBITORS AND SEROTONIN
AND NOREPINEPHRINE REUPTAKE INHIBITORS
Sertraline and paroxetine are currently the only FDA-approved SSRIs for PTSD.
Large controlled studies have demonstrated that both agents, as well as venlafaxine,
are effective and superior to placebo.
161 They also have beneficial effects on
depression and general anxiety symptoms and have been associated with
improvements in overall functioning and quality of life.
159,161 Use of fluoxetine also
appears to be effective in treating PTSD in some patients, although study results have
20,25 Citalopram, escitalopram, and fluvoxamine have shown efficacy in
159,162 Finally, one small, naturalistic
study in treatment-resistant men suggests duloxetine may be effective in managing
163 However, in another small, prospective study in
military veterans suggests additional studies are warranted.
Several open studies and case reports suggest nefazodone, mirtazapine, and
bupropion are effective in treating core symptoms of PTSD.
evidence for these antidepressants is not as strong, they may be considered
appropriate alternatives to SSRIs or venlafaxine in certain patients. The TCAs
amitriptyline and imipramine and the MAOI phenelzine have also been found to be
effective for PTSD in controlled trials, but these agents are generally not
recommended because of their poor tolerability and safety profiles.
relatively high risk of suicide in PTSD, TCAs can be especially dangerous in this
Various other medications have been used successfully in limited numbers of PTSD
cases. Anticonvulsants carbamazepine, valproate, topiramate, tiagabine, gabapentin,
oxcarbazepine, vigabatrin, pregabalin, levetiracetam, and lamotrigine have been
studied with inconsistent results, mostly in case series and open-label trials.
These agents may be effective in certain patients and can be useful for reducing
irritability, impulsivity, and anger or violent outbursts, particularly in patients with
study failed to find benefit with adjunctive use of risperidone in treatment-resistant
PTSD in military service personnel compared to placebo.
167 However, a recent metaanalysis suggests these agents may help target symptoms of intrusion.
adrenergic antagonist, prazosin, may decrease nightmares, increase sleep time, and
reduce other core symptoms in patients with PTSD.
155,169 Higher doses, up to 16
mg/day, may be needed to optimize efficacy.
170 Conflicting evidence exists for the use
of the β-adrenergic antagonist, propranolol, which has been studied in blocking
memory consolidation and therefore may prevent PTSD if administered within hours
171 Larger studies are needed to determine whether this is a
useful preventive option. As previously mentioned, preliminary evidence supports
the use of hydrocortisone for this indication, though additional studies are needed.
Benzodiazepines are generally ineffective in treating PTSD, and use of these agents
Various types of psychosocial therapies have been used in the treatment of PTSD,
including anxiety management training to help patients cope with stress.
172 Traumafocused CBT and eye movement desensitization and reprocessing treatment have both
demonstrated effectiveness in PTSD, and either of these treatments are recommended
140,158 Cognitive therapies seem to be most effective for
symptoms of demoralization, guilt, and shame, whereas exposure therapies are better
for reducing intrusive thoughts, flashbacks, and avoidance behaviors. Studies are
needed to further investigate the utility of virtual reality exposure therapy and
transcranial magnetic stimulation in PTSD.
173,174 Trials of combined psychosocial
therapies and medication are inconclusive and require further investigation to
determine superior effectiveness compared with either treatment strategy alone.
Clinical Presentation of Post-traumatic Stress Disorder
QUESTION 1: D.D. is a 42-year-old woman who was attacked and raped in the driveway of her home as
night (which she avoids doing when possible). She is startled when the phone rings or when someone
strain on her marriage. What clinical features of PTSD does D.D. display?
Individuals with PTSD often present with nonspecific complaints indicative of a
generalized anxiety, depression, or substance use disorder. They may not realize or
want to reveal an association between their symptoms and the trauma experienced.
Careful evaluation by the clinician is required to elicit a pattern suggestive of PTSD.
D.D. displays many target symptoms of PTSD, including re-experiencing/intrusive
symptoms (nightmares, recurrent memories), avoidance of the activity reminding her
of the trauma, symptoms of increased arousal (sleep difficulties, irritability,
exaggerated startle response), and negative alterations in cognition (guilt). In
addition, she is experiencing feelings of depression, distress, marital problems, and
impairment in occupational functioning as a result of her symptoms. The lack of any
previous psychiatric illness combined with the temporal relationship between the
attack and her symptoms supports the presence of PTSD as opposed to another
anxiety or depressive disorder. Since her trauma occurred 1 month ago, her condition
would be classified as acute-onset PTSD.
Treatment Selection and Selective Serotonin Reuptake
CASE 83-9, QUESTION 2: What factors are important in the selection of an initial treatment for D.D.?
Because D.D. is exhibiting moderate-to-severe PTSD symptoms, pharmacotherapy
is indicated. Medication treatment should be combined with CBT if it is available,
but nonpharmacologic therapies alone are generally reserved for patients with mild
symptoms. An SSRI is the preferred initial medication treatment for most patients.
Sertraline is an appropriate choice of treatment in this case and is FDA-approved for
PTSD. Low initial SSRI doses are recommended in PTSD, so sertraline can be
started at 25 mg/day and gradually increased to the target dosage range of 100 to 150
mg/day, according to response and tolerability.
165 Persistent sleep complaints during
the first month after a traumatic experience may predispose the patient to chronic
PTSD, so management of sleep disturbances is an important component of initial
No comments:
Post a Comment
اكتب تعليق حول الموضوع